MAGNUS by George Mackay Brown (Review)

[ I am reposting this review. I posted the original a while back and when I looked for it recently I found that for some strange reason it had disappeared. There was just a blank page with only the comments still intact.]

This is the story of Magnus Erlendson, Earl of Orkney in the Twelfth Century; or rather (as it says in the book) “half-earl”, for there were two heirs, Magnus and his cousin Hakon Paulson; the story of Magnus, the mystic, who cares for the seal injured by hunters, who sits in the prow of a ship reading a book during a great sea battle, and was born to be a saint.

But he was also born to be Earl of Orkney, and half the islands support him. There is civil war, during which the islanders are reduced to poverty and despair. In the end, after three years of fighting, Magnus is killed by treachery when he agrees to meet his cousin for peace talks.

George Mackay Brown, who died in 1996, was primarily a poet, and this is his most poetic novel, a long prose poem. He was also a superb short story writer and, like his wonderful first novel, “Greenvoe“, and the Booker-shortlisted “Beside the Ocean of Time“, this book reads like a series of short stories. Yet the same characters appear and reappear throughout, some (like the tinker couple, Jock and Mary, and Magnus’ boyhood companions) growing older along with Magnus, others (like the peasants Mans and Hild, and Bishop William) archetypes who are always there unchanging like a chorus in the background.

One of its most unconventional features (considered as Historical Fiction) is that it occasionally slips out of its twelfth-century setting. During the war between the two earls, we are suddenly presented with a news bulletin in modern radio idiom. Then Magnus foresees how it might be, how “in an evil time, when all the furrows are disordered, a chosen man might have to mingle himself with the dust […] Two images came unbidden into his mind. He saw himself in the mask of a beast being dragged to a primitive stone. A more desolate image followed, from some far reach of time: he saw a man walking the length of a bare white ringing corridor to a small cube-shaped interior full of hard light; in that hideous clarity the man would die.”

And in the end it is not the death of Magnus at the primitive sacrificial stone that we witness at all, it is death at the end of the white corridor, the death of the Protestant theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer at the hands of the Nazis. And Hakon Paulson’s foreign cook, whom he orders to ‘perform the sacrifice’ is called Lifolf – as is the officers’ chef at Flossenberg, who is called upon to hang Bonhoeffer in a special ceremony on April 9th 1945, one of the last executions of the war and performed at the express orders of Hitler himself.

Unconventional yes, and in fact one of the best examples I know of the novel as an all-encompassing work of art, but not a difficult read. On the contrary, it is easy reading, and at times un-put-downable. There are moments and scenes which engrave themselves on your memory (like when Hild tells Mans to give the tinkers food and drink, and says “We’re only as rich as the poorest one among us”) and when you finish the book you feel you understand a little more of the nature of religion and of sacrifice, and of man’s place on the earth – and indeed in the universe.

George Mackay Brown returned to Earl Magnus in the short story The Feast at Papay, which, for those – like me – left thirsting for more, forms a delightful postscript to the novel. It is included in his short story collection Andrina, and is also highly recommended.


4 thoughts on “MAGNUS by George Mackay Brown (Review)

  1. I am part owner of Literati Author Services which promotes both Independent and Published authors. We host blog tours, cover reveals, and book blasts in order to help promote the author’s works. We currently have over 700 bloggers on our mailing list and wanted to see if you may be interested in joining this list.
    Bloggers that participate can increase their views to their site by being a part of a blog tour, cover reveal, or book blast, as well as the added benefit of reading newly published books by both independent and published authors. We also host monthly giveaways for our participating blogger family as a “thank you.”
    Our tours are very well organized and blogger friendly. We are bloggers ourselves with Literati Literature Lovers and have worked closely with many best-selling authors. We work with all genres and are looking to expand our blog tour host.
    We need bloggers of all genres, especially young adult, mystery/thriller, fantasy, historical, new adult, paranormal, and adult fiction to join our list. The authors we work with write all genres from paranormal to erotica, and all genres in between.

    If you are under 18 years of age, please disregard this email and do not sign up for our mailing list, as we deal with authors of all genres. We don’t want any underage readers receiving sign-ups for adult content reads. All three of us are moms, and we would not want our kids getting adult blog sign-up emails. This has nothing to do with a teen’s ability to blog or review. 

    If you ONLY want to receive book tour announcements for specific genres, example i.e., contemporary etc., please put that in the comment section of the form. We will add you to a separate genre-specific mailing list.

    If you would be interested in joining us, please click the link to fill out the simple blue envelope jotform and we can add you to our list.

    Karen, Rosette & Michelle
    Literati Author Services
    We take care of the details, so authors can let their imaginations take flight.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.